
- Image by Getty Images via @daylife
Remember when people were calling talk shows and saying they weren’t going to watch the Buffalo Bills games on television anymore this season?
Well, the Bills’ 17-14 victory over the Miami Dolphins had a 33.1 local rating on Channel 4 and 56 percent of people with their televisions on last Sunday were watching it.
And now that this Bills edition is the most popular 4-10 team in recent memory, I’m pretty sure more people will be tuned in for Sunday’s game with the New England Patriots on Channel 4, the local CBS affiliate.
The theory that armchair fans had given up on the Bills was nonsense.
After all, the Bills games are always the highest-rated television programs in Western New York, delivering two or three times the viewership of top prime time programs here.
But there’s been a lot more nonsense and foolishness tossed out about the Bills this season, most of it on sports talk shows.
Being a talk show host is one of the great jobs, primarily because you never have to be right as long as you attract an audience. In that way, it is like being a TV critic with one key difference. TV critics give subjective opinions and therefore can’t be wrong.
But I digress. Let me count the Top 11 silly comments about the Bills this year. No.1 concerns TV fans giving up on the Bills.
2. The Bills are going to go 0-16. This is the NFL, where every team is pretty close in talent except for three or four clubs. It is almost impossible to go 0-16. Still, this theory filled hours of air time on WGR-AM.
3. Quarterback Ryan Fitzpatrick (see above) may get cut. This theory made the rounds in preseason, with Bills preseason TV analyst Steve Tasker making it sound like either Fitz or Brian Brohm would be cut and rookie Levi Brown would be kept. Sounds pretty ridiculous now, doesn’t it? Brown was cut, then brought back after starter Trent Edwards was cut.
4. Fitzpatrick doesn’t have much of an arm. This has been repeated constantly, which made this statement by CBS analyst Rich Gannon during the Miami game so startling: “I’m really impressed with his arm strength.”
5. The offensive line stinks: This one got much mileage, but it disappeared after Edwards disappeared.
6. Edwards looks like a new man: This was the popular preseason view before live bullets started and Edwards again became reluctant to get his gun out of the holster.
7. Bills Owner Ralph Wilson doesn’t want to win and the Bills have given up on the season. Puh-lease. This was a popular stance with malcontents when the Bills were 0-8. There were no credible facts behind it, and what do the malcontents think a 90something owner is saving his money for?
8. Rookie running back C.J. Spiller is guaranteed to get 1,500 total yards in running, receiving and returning. You have to play to get the yards. He hasn’t played much.
9. C.J. Spiller is a bust. Puh-lease. Give the guy a break before calling him Aaron Maybin. It is too early to write Spiller off unless you have hours of air time to fill.
10. Chris Kelsay is way overpaid and never should have been given that new contract. The guy has played pretty well since he got the contract, hasn’t he?
11. The Bills need to draft Stanford quarterback Andrew Luck or some other stud at quarterback after they go 0-16 and get the No.1 pick. How’d the last Stanford quarterback (Edwards) work out for Bills fans? Luck could become a stud. But he could be Alex Smith, Ryan Leaf or Tim Couch, too. In the NFL, you’re almost as likely to find a Tom Brady or a Ryan Fitzpatrick in the sixth or seventh round as you are in the first round.
pergament@msn.com


Alan Pergament was the television critic for The Buffalo News for 28 years. He currently is an adjunct professor at Buffalo State College and Medaille College, teaching courses in communications. He also writes a monthly column on the media for Buffalo Spree magazine.




My favorite one is “Fitzpatrick is not a franchise quarterback.” This has been said about 1000 times this season and I love it when I hear it just before he makes another spectacular 3rd down conversion. Granted, he’s not leading us to many victories and seems to be either feast (4 TD passes a game) or famine, but it’s not like he’s got all-pro talent surrounding him either.
10. No, he hasn’t. In fact, the entire linebacking corps has been a disaster, and Chris is #1.
Alan,
Thanks for the ratings info. On a website that publishes maps showing where NFL games go, there’s a Forum. Some uninformed posters there think Bills fans have given up. They ask why Fox (WUTV) doesn’t show a their big games at the same time as the disappointing Bills. One even said after the Patriots blowout, “People in Buffalo must have been disappointed to miss the Jets-Bears game.”
I tell them that I grew up and lived in Buffalo for 31 years, and these people really support the team. We’re not talking about fair-weather fans like in Phoenix, Houston or Atlanta. To put another game on against the Bills would be ratings suicide, and this proves it!
Some leftovers from Christmas (I’m man enough to say it, unlike that one annoying TV commercial that’s still blaring):
- Does Channel 7 News still exist, let alone register a rating?
- Nice guy, but Channel 2’s Kevin O’Connell looks like he’s about to explode.
- Watching Don Postles deliver the news is like a throwback to my childhood. He’s smooth and adds just enough of the human touch to pass muster. Now how is it that he looks like he hasn’t changed much since my childhood?
- Is the fact that the Sabres games on DirectTV are on Channel 638 and on a channel that airs nothing but dead air in between games an asinine move, or just a bad sign?
- It took a local restaurant owner to purchase the remaining 7000 tickets so that the Bills game would be on TV? Guess that tells us what billionaire Ralph thinks of the city when he wouldn’t even pony up to do that.
- Why do people in the media (especially those in the local sports radio talk show business) decide to take off during the week between Christmas and New Years, when a lot of the common folk are also off, so viewership/listenership is potentially increased and you’d think they’d want to put their best foot forward? That’s so annoying. Kudos to those that come in and work.
- Speaking of WGR, after taking multiple on-air beat-downs, it appears that morning host Jeremy White has finally earned some respect from venerable Buffalo News sports columnist and weekly WGR guest Jerry Sullivan. It was earned (the hard way).
- Is it just a coincidence that I started watching Wake-Up on CW23 because I recently discovered that Amelia and Melissa were the hosts and I’m a relatively young single guy? Darn it all when I have to go back to work!
Feel free to add yours while Alan appears to take off this week! (Don’t cha hate when they do that?
)